Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Scenarica's avatar

The €44 versus €127 spread between Spain and Italy is the entire energy transition debate resolved in a single price chart. Forget the climate arguments for a moment. This is a competitiveness story now.

Every energy-intensive industry in Europe, data centres, manufacturing, chemical processing, aluminium smelting, is currently running a location analysis. The inputs to that analysis are power cost, grid reliability, and political stability. Spain scores well on all three simultaneously. Germany at €96 with industrial electricity costs already double the US rate is actively losing manufacturers. Italy at €127 is losing them faster. Spain at €44 is positioned to catch the businesses those countries are shedding.

The Hormuz insulation is the part of this story that has immediate relevance and I havent seen it discussed anywhere in these terms. Spain generates 44% of its electricity from wind and solar and only 17% from fossil fuels. That means Spanish wholesale prices are largely decoupled from the Hormuz oil shock that is driving gas prices across the rest of Europe. Germany and Italy are paying a Hormuz premium on thier electricity because their grids still depend on gas. Spain isnt. That price differential will widen every week the Strait stays closed.

The 2022 crossover point where wind plus solar overtook all fossil generation combined is the structural inflection that makes this irreversable. Once you've built enough renewable capacity to push gas off the marginal pricing unit for most hours of the year, the wholesale price structurally decouples from commodity markets. Spains electricity price now moves with weather patterns and grid demand rather than with Henry Hub or TTF gas futures. Thats energy independence measured in euros per megawatt-hour rather than in political speeches.

The cautionary tale to tech leader pipeline is remarkable. A decade ago Spain was the example of how NOT to do solar policy. Now its the example of what happens when you survive the policy mistakes and the underlying economics take over.

Gene Frenkle's avatar

I like the VAT because I reduced my utility bills by 90% with a highly efficient mini split and the units are super cheap. So post pandemic I started noticing my HVAC repair bills started out at $250 and by last year they were $1k a pop! My mini splits cost around $500 a unit and everyone gets an ideal temp and my utility bill is significantly cheaper. I do have a natural gas fireplace that I believe is necessary for power outages but that bill was only expensive during the record cold snap in February and it was still significantly cheaper than my previous utility bill. Once I get a battery backup then the natural gas fireplace will only be used at night during the rare polar vortex.

26 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?